What About Weed Control?

weed control, newspaper weed control, blue jean weed control, biodegradable weed control,

Nature doesn’t appreciate the bare earth method we call “weeding.” The soil we count on to grow our veggies and flowers isn’t just a blank medium for our gardening whims. It’s a fragile, complex, living system that’s home to bacteria, fungi, and other life forms busy beneath our feet.

Left alone, nature brings forth plants of all kinds that improve the soil’s ability to foster life. We call them weeds. They seem to spring up without reason other than to frustrate us. But nature has her reasons.

~Many of these plants boost the presence of mycorrhiza.  This beneficial fungi massively improves a plant’s ability to use the soil’s water and nutrients while providing protection from certain pathogens. Mycorrhizas are found in more than 90 percent of plant families but its presence is inhibited by too much fertilizer and it can be destroyed by excessive digging, tilling, and soil compaction.

~Many of these plants help to break up heavy soil with strong root systems, aerating and improving drainage.

~Many of these plants improve soil fertility. Some fix nitrogen, some draw trace elements  from deep in the ground and transport them closer to the surface.

In places where the soil is lacking, the right plants to correct those particular deficiencies tend to spring up. In fact, botanists know that weeds are an indicator of soil properties such as pH and mineral levels. That’s nature’s wisdom at work.

Then we come in, gardeners and farmers, doing our darndest to get down to bare ground between rows of plants. Many of us know that bare ground is scalded by the sun, and topsoil is washed away by wind and rain but old habits die hard.

I want to understand the weeds that nature bestows on me. For example, I respect the fierce tenacity of thistles that can quickly grow taller than I am. And I can’t help but adore the beauty of those delicate flowers atop such a prickly stem. They’ve visited most fiercely in our front flower bed, one that was mounded up from subsoil left when our septic system was excavated. I know and nature knows the soil there isn’t very hospitable to life. That’s why thistles are there. I’ve augmented that bed with cow manure dragged from the back of our property, stacked it with layers of straw and mulch, and pulled out as many thistles as  I can before my strength gives out. What’s interesting is thistles are dynamic accumulators that work to bring up deep nutrients and their long roots break up poor soil.  What’s also interesting is that that fewer thistles appear in that bed every year, as if they’re completing a job started nearly 15 years ago. Other weeds are now taking their place, surely just as necessary.

But respect for weeds goes only so far. It’s not possible to grow peas, lettuce, and other delicate plants in a jungle of weeds. Besides, I am a low energy lazy gardener. Once summer heat rolls in I’m more inclined to hide in the shade with a book than sweat with Puritan righteousness in the sun.

So I have lots of experience with weed control methods.  (Other than chemical, I don’t go there.)

Your great grandparents’ aerobics.

~Hoeing. I’m not good at hoeing, although that may have something to do with using an antique implement that probably hasn’t been sharpened for decades. My hoeing technique also probably leaves something to be desired. Finally, the whole hoeing experience is impaired by having three dogs out with me, dogs that like to dash after each other in wild canine exuberance putting them right in the way of my hoe.

Rip em out.

~Weeding. I’m not good at pulling weeds either but that’s the method I use most often. As I pull weeds, I lay their still-green bodies between the rows as a natural mulch. I tend to sit on the ground as I hand weed, and I happen to like how close that puts me to the smell of growth and the sight of tiny insects and an overall greater awareness of what’s going on in the garden. The size of my various gardens makes it impossible to do this well unless I want to spend many many hours a week on my butt pulling weeds, which I do until the blazing heat hits. Then I do so fewer hours with greater grumpiness.

Landscape fabric is evil.

~Landscape fabric. We were given reams of this by a friend of a friend who used to run a greenhouse. It wasn’t easy to get between the rows and batten down with clips, but I covered it with straw and grass clipping and it looked great. I was thrilled. It worked well until I pulled it off at the end of the growing season. The soil looked awful, cracked and strange as if it had boiled under all that black fabric. Rather than being soft and friable it was hard. I wanted to beg the dirt’s forgiveness. I was also rather bitter, as this was the easiest thing we ever used. It also has to be pulled up every year or it’ll accumulate so much biomass on its surface that plants will simply grow on top of it.

Weed control using newspapers and straw

~Newspapers and straw. I read about the newspaper and straw method years ago in Mother Earth News, and have been doing it on and off ever since. Basically you layer heavy, overlapping sheets of newspaper between the rows covered by straw or grass clippings. By the end of the growing season it’s largely biodegraded and is dirt by the next spring. I have a love/hate thing going with this method, probably because I’ve made all the mistakes possible. Too little newspaper, straw so flimsy that it doesn’t break into sections that firmly hold anything down. And the worst, trying to put down newspaper when there’s any breeze at all. This year I’m doing most of the garden this way. Again, making mistakes. This time I laid down quite a few rows and got the straw nicely set atop those papers but didn’t dampen it with rain barrel water because the sky threatened rain within minutes. Bad idea. That rain appeared only after heavy gusts of wind, meaning I was running around the yard trying to catch windborne newspaper and stomping my feet in Rumplestiltskin fits of frustration. [2014 update. Used heavy paper feedbags are even better than newspapers. Just cut open, spread out, cover with straw, and water. Be sure to avoid feedbags with plastic lining!]

VLUU L200  / Samsung L200

My silly idea, jeans as weed control.~

~Jeans, yes jeans are this year’s innovation. I got into the pile jeans I’ve been saving to make a quilt (the kind perfect to keep in a car trunk for impromptu picnics). I slashed them apart, laid them in rows of emerging garlic plants while my kids laughed at crazy mom, then covered them with straw. I don’t know if they’ll biodegrade or if I’ll have to pull them up, but I’m thrilled with how well they’re staying put. [2014 update. Jeans work well and biodegrade in about two years, although the heavy seams are still here and there in places. Probably best to use between perennials.]

What do YOU do to live with and live without weeds?

About Laura Grace Weldon

Laura Grace Weldon is the author of four books and served as 2019 Ohio Poet of the Year. She's the editor of Braided Way: Faces & Voices of Spiritual Practice. She works as a book editor, teaches writing workshops, and maxes out her library card each week.
This entry was posted in gardening, invasive, soil, weeds and tagged , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

21 Responses to What About Weed Control?

  1. Sharon says:

    I guess I’m like you: I do a little bit of everything when it comes to weeds. When I dig my garden, I try to get out as many grass roots as possible. Afterward, I hoe and handweed, depending on whether I happen to have the hoe with me when I see that something needs doing. Some weeds I leave, especially in the spring garden: thinks like chickweed, hairy bittercress, mouse-ear chickweed. When they get big or threaten to seed themselves, I pull them up (they come up in big clumps) and use them as mulch. I’ve also started using some straw mulch, and I have to say, I love the way the soil looks under that. Very loose and moist. So I may be trying to introduce more straw as time goes by. We’ll see!

  2. tlryder says:

    We made the mistake of leaving our landscape fabric down too long last year and wow was it a mess to dig out. This year I’m hand weeding and mulching, and occasionally using my “claw” (the fork version of a hoe) on stubborn grass. The jeans thing sounds inspired to me. The thrift store here is full of cheap jeans in tiny women’s sizes that few humans can fit in. I’m going to price it out. I suspect jeans would be cheaper than landscape fabric! We don’t wear enough jeans as a family to have many used pairs laying around, alas.

    • Laura Weldon says:

      If you can, get the biggest jeans possible. The more fabric, the more space you can cover. I’m starting to think about other fabrics, burlap in particular, as I think it might actually biodegrade by the next spring. If you do some experimenting, let me know!

  3. KrisBordessa says:

    I’ve actually been toying with a similar idea: 100% cotton tshirts. My local thrift store sells a bag of shirts for $1 and I think the cloth will work perfectly on a hillside of weeds I’m fighting. (Also? I’ve done that breezy day, chase the newspaper thing. I like cardboard better.)

    • Laura Weldon says:

      I always wondered about cardboard, specifically if it had glues or other hidden nasties that I might not want to leach into the ground.

      Funny story. A friend lined her garden with cardboard, specifically opened pizza boxes. Turned out that used pizza boxes are not a good idea. Those greasy spots are too alluring for raccoons and other creatures. Every single morning those boxes had been dragged a few feet away.

      T-shirts could be good! If you staked them down with landscape fabric clips it would make the hillside look like a quilt. Would love to see those photos. Do you think they’ll decompose in a few months or will you have to pull them up?

  4. Karyn @ kloppenmum says:

    I have new respect for the nettles and thistles that keep coming back! I hand weed. But like your jeans idea. You could put old woollen blankets down too – I am going to try that this winter on the beds that are sleeping.

  5. A LYS says:

    We have tried many methods and we like lasagna (works well, takes time) or woodchip (described in the Back to Eden movie) both using lots of compost. If you do not put a cover over compost, the soil just bakes and the compost washes away. Hope this helps someone save time and water and be productive.

  6. jodancingtree says:

    I use cardboard on top of bare ground, or sod that I want to get rid of (not pizza boxes) and spread grass clippings over that in summer. In the fall I pile on 6 inches or so of leaves, and lay long sticks on top to keep them from blowing away. By the following spring the cardboard has disappeared and I just rake the mulch aside to plant, then layer new grass clippings around them as the summer progresses. In the fall, back to leaves again. My soil is beautiful, and full of earthworms.

  7. Natalie says:

    I have used all sorts of old clothes before (hard work wears them out pretty fast, huh?), all natural materials of course. We did a layer of clothes, compost/aged manure, then straw (really thick). That seemed to suppress everything except bindweed! And our poor soil quickly filled with worms, and hopefully other beneficials. The clothes didn’t break down too quickly, but we are in a pretty dry climate and don’t water over the winter.

    As for other weeding, I try to leave as many roots in the ground as possible. So, if they are annual weeds I use a hoe/scythe (or the goats if possible!) or hand pull if they are perennial.

  8. I live by mulch (20+ years) because don’t have time to weed, but I keep it thick. I’ve tried straw (it grew oats, or maybe it was wheat – never again), rotten hay is a favorite, if I can get it, but I have to pay someone to deliver (if you keep the mulch thick any weeds don’t have a chance). My neighbor has a clean lawn and he tends to dump his lawn clippings – I beg when I see him mowing!

    I collect lawnmower chopped leaves and grass from a nearby suburb where they put it curbside for the town to suck up and mulch. It’s cleaner than urban sources (too much litter, gravel, etc.) no one cares, and it’s free.

    Weed control during the year for certain plants would be helpful (squash, maybe), and I saw your post about old jeans – must try that! Haven’t made mine into the quilts I wanted, so I like the idea of using them around certain plants. Have you continued using them, and have you any further advice/tips?

    • Ah, thick mulch is a wise solution indeed, enriching the soil and saving your back. The struggle is getting enough of it. My favorite is rain-soaked straw, which we stack around the chicken coop to help insulate and deter predators during the winter, then in spring use in the garden. There’s just never enough.

      Grass clippings and chopped leaves, once they’ve compacted can work well but I don’t have any trusted sources. We don’t collect our lawn clippings and I hesitate to collect those from lawns that do since so many people use weed control on their lawns.

      The best thing I’ve found is plant in wide rows, laying newspaper or cardboard close around and between the plants. I top that topped with old straw or other mulch. Then I can weed whack between the rows, which looks almost like a lawn (of nicely trimmed weeds) through the growing season. It’s a lot less labor-intensive than weeding.

      Here’s more on that. https://bitofearthfarm.wordpress.com/2016/08/29/the-method-is-the-mindset/

      • As you say, there’s just never enough mulch. I am just glad that the homes where I collect my fall mulch have children who play in the yards, so they don’t do chemicals. If they weren’t so unwieldy to unwrap and use in my city yard, I would request and pay for delivery of rotting round bales of hay that I see along the edges of various farms. They are perfect. I have searched for water damaged bales intended for livestock feed, and have even considered talking to organic grass fed dairies to beg for occasional seasonal delivery of dairy bedding. It’s never-ending and being creative is essential.

  9. These are all wonderful ideas. Dairy bedding, once rotted down, would be amazing!

  10. Katie Breen says:

    How did this all work out? Actually was about to throw out some old crotch ripped jeans & got curious. I’ve used these old piece for pot holders before but we are getting our garden really growing & love using old needless things for actual functional stuff we do need. How’d it all turn out ?

    • Jeans actually worked really well at keeping weeds down that whole first growing season. And I enjoyed noticing a gleam of a rivet or the way the fabric wore thin as if worn by the ground. But jeans were a one-year solution here. I pulled up most of them in late fall (again the problem of biomass being wasted as it clung to the fabric). I didn’t get every bit up, so the next spring I tried planting around the sturdier pieces I’d left. As the fabric left long strings of fiber in the soil. We don’t use a rototiller but if we did those strings would be a problem.

      The solution I now use is to leave weed-whacker sized space between rows. I cut a square of cardboard (or heavy paper feed sack) cut a reasonable hole in the middle, and place it on the ground putting the plant in the center. The cardboard is held down either with climbing cages or straw (heavy wet straw that’s left over from insulating the chicken coop all winter). No tearing weeds out, the weeds instead are trimmed the the weed whacker or push mower. Their roots stay in the ground, holding soil in and keeping the networks of mycellium intact. Win win!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s